Imaginary Friends

Unspoken by Sarah Rees Brennan
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

A few plot holes mar this otherwise excellent kick-ass girl mystery. Kami is a great main character -- fearless, smart, funny AND she has had an imaginary friend all her life! (I wish I could have held on to mine. I miss you, Suzanne Davis!) She and Jared talk to each in their minds all the time and it's great. Okay, so they don't think too much about it, because doing that makes them wonder about their sanity . . . as in "really? I have apparently made up a whole life for my imaginary friend?" As long as they don't think to closely about it, it's cool -- there's always someone to talk to, to comfort and commiserate with.

And then they meet IRL. Oh dear.

Isn't that a terrific set up? I'm in awe -- what an absolutely brilliant concept for a paranormal novel!

But honestly, if you were told about some sinister happening in an abandoned mansion out in the boonies which no adults will tell you about, would your first step be to go there? Or might you check the local archives in the library or the newspaper office? Especially considering you do know that you can check local history in the library and the newspaper office? Hmmm? Aside from the creep factor, this is why I have trouble with reading scary books -- the characters do such stupid things.

I'll take off my grinchy hat now and admit that I have already looked up when book 2 is scheduled for publication -- next October! Woo-hoo!!


View all my reviews

Thinking about reality

One of our long time library friends loaned me Listening for Madeleine: A Portrait of Madeleine L'Engle in Many Voices, by Leonard S. Marcus. What a fascinating read!

I'm sure you all know of Madeleine L'Engle's books -- A Wrinkle in Time, Meet the Austins, A Circle of Quiet, etc. etc. She was a prolific author of books filled with the wonder of family and the world. Ms. L'Engle was an outspoken defender of the freedom to read and generously gave of her time to other writers, readers and librarians.

As was made public in a notorious New Yorker article published in 2004, she also was an accomplished editor, excising unpleasant or unflattering truths from her journals before publication and retooling memories to suit herself. In Listening for Madeleine, Marcus interviews people from all parts of Ms. L'Engle's life to try to capture the full story of a larger-than-life personality, and presents the resulting stories pretty much as is. I was rapt.

He's taken some flak, Cynthia Zarin (of the New Yorker profile) has taken some flak, Ms. L'Engle's daughters have certainly taken some flak, for exposing misery and ugliness in her life, but I'm grateful. These interviews remind me that people are multi-faceted, that memory is flexible, and that learning and growing as a human being means we must work through our personal demons, sometimes in very public ways. I am sorry that her family was harmed by her writings and her denial, and yet I still love The Twenty Four Days before Christmas and A Ring of Endless Light and Two-Part Invention.

A Wrinkle in Time introduced young readers to the concept of other, unknown dimensions. I appreciate being reminded that people, too, have many dimensions, known and unknown.