A Reader Responds...

Lindi has written about darkening her days of summer with heavy books, and makes a good case to pick these up when the sun arrives early to erase any dark thoughts caused by reading about violence and grief. But for me, summer reading remains more indulgent. While propped uncomfortably in a tent, trying to get the headlamp to illuminate the words, nothing but a lurid mystery will do. When faced with a weekend with the extended family, several generations talking all at once in the same space, then a YA novel with urgent plot lines and breathy incomplete sentences is the only thing I can focus on. And when the nights turn sticky and the open windows bring no relief, well, then it is time to turn on the TV and hope for the best.

Winter, on the other hand, is the time for sturdier stuff. Well researched historical fictions in which characters scheme and drink flagons of white mead take my mind off car pool rotations, homework supervision and menu planning. Three part Victorian tomes fill the long nights, stretched on the couch, nearly napping. Chapters of award winning novels fill the minutes of waiting in a pick-up line. Reading about polar explorers stuck on the ice in fierce blizzards put my own struggles to drive up the slightly snowy hill into perspective. I’m looking forward to all of that. Winter is coming!

Of course, the best books are those that have no season, those that are well written and memorable as well as being entertaining. I read two this summer that stand out among the rest: Longbourn by Jo Baker and Mr. Penumbra’s 24-Hour Bookstore by Robin Sloan.

It would be easy to say that Longbourn is the downstairs to the upstairs of Pride and Prejudice, but that summary misses that point of this original and fully imagined novel. Think of a household with 5 daughters in the days before maxi-pads. Guess who had to wash the rags! When Elizabeth Bennett famously sets off to Netherfield in the mud, Sarah the housemaid knows the pink Persian silk dress will be ruined. When Mr. Collins arrives at short notice for his twelve day stay, Mrs. Hill the housekeeper knows there is no time to properly air and buff the guest chamber and so makes do with a spray of evergreen and berries in a vase and goes off to roast a hen with parsnips. James grooms the horses and takes the family to the balls and dinner parties. But the book is not merely about cold mornings and chilblains and cooked chicken. The characters are all fully realized with secrets of their own. The writing is a dream to read and the plot pulls you along. While it probably helps to have read Pride and Prejudice, this novel stands on its own. Rest assured the story of Sarah and James is as romantic as anything Jane Austen can pen.

Mr. Penumbra is also a romance of sorts, illuminating the way old books and high tech can mingle and support each other. The plot is a bit farfetched - employees of the titular bookstore race across the country to discover secret reading rooms, arcane book societies, hunt down type punches (the literal printing fonts) and make book scanners out of cardboard and computer chips. Somehow the goose chase of a plot doesn’t matter because it is such fun to read about the discoveries. Written with wit and imbued with creative ideas, this book zips along breezily, until the final emotional punch at the end. Unlike The Circle by Dave Eggers which is a heavy handed screed against Google, Mr. Penumbra enthusiastically embraces all kinds of reading. So, if a heady combination of topics as unrelated as Aldus Manutius, rock climbing, fantasy fiction, secret societies, research, type fonts, 3-D models, and tall ladders hold any interest, this is a book for you.

Today it is warm, but rainy. The days are getting shorter, but it is definitely still summer. Back to my mystery.

Summer Reading Recap, Grown-Up Edition

Hey y'all!

It's summer! And what a glorious summer Seattle is having this year! Temperatures consistently in the 80s with a few 90+ days sprinkled in, day after day of sun. It has been one for the books... and I mean the record books.

But as long as we're talking about books, let me bend your ear about what I've been reading. People talk about "beach reads" and "chick lit" for the summer, and yeah, I read my share of what I call popcorn, but I also tend to reserve my dark and serious books for these bright days. Don't want to be reading depressing stuff when it's dark at 3:30 in the afternoon, oh no.

So what stands out for me in the grown-up fiction realm this summer? Number one is definitely An Untamed State, by Roxane Gay. Followers of this blog will remember that last May I was eagerly anticipating its publication. [Quick plot recap for those who need it, Mireille is a Miami woman kidnapped while visiting her parents in Haiti and held for 13 days before she is released.] The novel exceeded my expectations. It's harrowing and there are some scenes where I just had to pretend I didn’t know what was going on. It’s also authentic, hopeful and compassionate. Gay very skillfully writes about violence without titillation of any kind. I can imagine a person reading some of the torture scenes in The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo and, well, getting off a little. You know? It's hard to resist the push of our culture's misogyny and glorification of violence. I mean, look at Fifty Shades of Grey. But Gay does not allow that in her writing. Mireille has had a bad thing, a series of bad things, happen to her. They are done by men, and Gay's not giving the reader anything but the ugly truth about that. One Goodreads reviewer said that for her, “An Untamed State is about what a woman absorbs.” That’s succinct and true, just like Gay’s beautiful writing. Another theme that stands out in An Untamed State is the notion of before and after in a life. Mireille's imprisonment and recovery both are dark and hard. The after isn't necessarily her release from the kidnappers.

The second novel I loved this summer is The Possibilities, by Kaui Hart Hemmings, a thoughtful book of grief and resilience. Hemmings is probably better known as the writer of The Descendants, which was made into a George Clooney movie a few years back. Like her more famous book, The Possibilities is about relationships’ complexities. Here’s my Goodreads review: “You know how you know and love someone; you think you know them better than themselves maybe even? And you love them, deeply, warts and all? And then they do something surprising. Not out of character, because that suggests they're an actor. Just something that you didn't see coming. That's how this novel is. Hemmings has written a book about long-time friendship and love and family, and I thought I could see where it was going, but then she surprised me with moments so perfect, so unexpected -- the whole novel captures that essence of how complicated and multi-layered people are.”

Stay tuned for more mini-reviews of what we read this summer. Now back to the sunshine… where’s my book?

Anticipation

What are you looking forward to reading this summer? On the top of my list are Roxane Gay's An Untamed State and Donna Tartt's The Goldfinch. I've got my hands on a copy of the latter, but it's enormous! And I just don't think the short intervals of reading time I currently have available will accommodate its heft. It will be nice to have time to savor this book that won Ms Tartt the Pulitzer and that several friends have pronounced fabulous.

An Untamed State has just been released and I'm on the reserve list at Seattle Public Library. I've been following Roxane Gay on Twitter for some time. Have you heard of her? She writes a lot, and teaches at an Illinois university, and did I mention she writes a lot? She's smart, articulate and provides a perspective I have not seen before. She always makes me feel smarter, because she's clearly intelligent and I understand what she's writing. You can read an utterly heartbreaking essay about loneliness and love and reality television in yesterday's NY Times here, a pointed criticism of bell hooks criticizing Beyoncé's feminism here, and a spirited defense of unlikeable female protagonists here.

In her new novel, Gay is gathering glowing reviews for her writing, characters and honesty. Mireille is a wealthy Haitian woman who is kidnapped. This is, apparently, kind of business as usual in Haiti -- people are kidnapped; their friends and family pay the ransom; everyone wins. But that doesn't happen for Mireille. Her father refuses to pay and, oh dear. Now it's bad. Privilege and power, wealth and class, how to overcome devastating trauma -- Gay addresses some weighty issues here. It sounds utterly harrowing, and I don't usually do harrowing, but it also sounds too good to miss.

On a lighter note, Rainbow Rowell's fourth book, her second novel for adults, is due out in July. Landline follows a couple having marital trouble -- like who doesn't a few years and couple kids down the line? -- but Georgie may have busted the relationship for good this time. Until she stumbles on an unusual way to communicate with her husband that can maybe make a difference. Rowell's characters are true to life and they have great (and believeable) conversations. The books are funny and wise and sexy. I'm going to click on over to SPL right now and see if it's too early to put Landline on reserve.

What's on your summer reading list?

E-Books

We recently weeded our non-fiction collection and shifted things a bit to make more room in fiction. It is a school library, after all, and by far our fiction collection gets the most action. The shelves are so pretty now, with room for expansion and display. I occasionally visit those stacks just to delight in a job well done.

As I shifted the Frances Hodgson Burnetts and the Hilary McKays and the J.K Rowlings, there were the odd adult authors -- Tolstoy and Steinbeck and Bronte. It occurred to me that these shelf hogs are taking up valuable real estate! If we bought them through Overdrive, our digital content provider, we would have them to read and we get shelf space for more great children's literature -- win, win.

Do you use an ereader? Have you checked out our catalog online? It includes our physical collection as well as the Overdrive titles. See a librarian to learn how to download our digital content.

Boosterism

Hey sports fans! The countdown is ON! Superbowl Sunday is almost here! Who are you rooting for -- Denver or our home town favorite, Seattle Public Library? That's right, 12th readers! We are headed to a smackdown! Tweet what you are reading to @SPLBuzz with the tag #SEAreads and/or #ReadingBowl. Show that Seattle is the most literate city!

And whil we are choosing sides, are you Team Bronte or Team Austen? Do you cheer for Edward & Bella or Beka Cooper? Or maybe you're a Katniss backer.

Does Cinderella (Ever After, Just Ella, Ella Enchanted) bring you to your feet or are your hurrahs for Rapunzel (Tangled, Book of a Thousand Days, Zel, Rapunzel's Revenge)?

Is your armchair quarterbacking aimed at the Donner Party or the American Revolution or the Civil War (Nathan Hale's Hazardous Tales)?

Which game could you have changed?

Fan Fiction

I heard Marcie Sillman interviewing Tom Keogh on KUOW recently about why Sherlock Holmes is such an enduring character and he called the modern day BBC series with Benedict Cumberbatch glorified fan fiction. Cool! Fan fiction is totally getting its day in the limelight!

You know what it is, right? It's pretty self-explanatory -- fans of published stories (books, games, movies) take the characters and settings, and play with them. It's been around for ages, but the Internet made it possible for amateur writers to easily share their vision with others. Some of those stories have been picked up and published in their own right. The fan fiction world I'm most familiar with is Jane Austen -- there are numerous web sites and I daren't actually go there! But I do know that a number of the Austen spin-offs (Pamela Aidan's trilogy and Sharon Lathan's series, for example) started as writings online that gained enough of a following that book deals resulted. Cassandra Clare (The Mortal Instruments) got her start writing Harry Potter fan fiction and E.L. James' 50 Shades of Grey started out on a Twilight fan fic site.

I love that people can hone their writing skills and get immediate feedback from readers. I am intrigued that the phenomenon can lead to publication. As a reader who loves living in my book worlds, it is appealing to have more access to my favorite characters. I may not agree with how another author imagines Miss Anne Elliot, for example, but I'm happy to visit her version.

What do you think -- is it cheating? Is it plagiarism? These characters were developed by writers who make a living by publishing books; why is it okay for others to use them? That's the question Cath in Rainbow Rowell's Fangirl has to answer for herself. In her mind, her stories are kind of like taking Star Wars action figures and making up new adventures, but that logic doesn't fly with her college writing professor. Does the fact that virtually all fan fic is written by fans for other fans and that money is not part of the equation matter?

Something to think about...

Unlikable Characters

Roxane Gay, my most recent writer crush, has a very thought-provoking article in Buzzfeed about unlikable characters, specifically unlikable women characters. That link is here, but this is the most awesome defense of characters we love to hate by Claire Messud, from the Gay essay:

In a Publisher’s Weekly interview with Claire Messud about her recent novel The Woman Upstairs, which features a rather “unlikable” protagonist named Nora who is bitter, bereft, and downright angry about what her life has become, the interviewer said, “I wouldn't want to be friends with Nora, would you? Her outlook is almost unbearably grim.” And there we have it. A reader was here to make friends with the characters in a book and she didn't like what she found.

Messud, for her part, had a sharp response for her interviewer. “For heaven's sake, what kind of question is that? Would you want to be friends with Humbert Humbert? Would you want to be friends with Mickey Sabbath? Saleem Sinai? Hamlet? Krapp? Oedipus? Oscar Wao? Antigone? Raskolnikov? Any of the characters in The Corrections? Any of the characters in Infinite Jest? Any of the characters in anything Pynchon has ever written? Or Martin Amis? Or Orhan Pamuk? Or Alice Munro, for that matter? If you're reading to find friends, you're in deep trouble. We read to find life, in all its possibilities. The relevant question isn't ‘Is this a potential friend for me?’ but ‘Is this character alive?’”

Wow! Just wow! Isn't that the truth? What would Charlotte's Web be without Templeton? Boring, that's what! 

I often say that I have to love the characters to love a book. Like Messud's hapless interviewer, it's often because I want them to be good people. On my first reading of Emma, for example, I was horrified. Reading about Jane Austen's privileged young woman meddling in her neighbors' lives was terribly uncomfortable for me. I was embarrassed for her. As I have grown as a reader though, I have to come to realize that having to love a book's character/s is not so much about goodness, as it is about recognizing these people, and more importantly, recognizing myself in them. 

My favorite books have characters that I believe in, that I can trust to behave authentically, whether or not I want to share a pie with them. Furthermore, my favorite characters have something to show me about myself. Sometimes that's a good thing and sometimes it's really unpleasant, but in the end I am always glad I made their acquaintance.